On Patriotism

Published: July 5, 2010

By Jim Lichtman
Image
Read More

After losing all four limbs to a roadside bomb on Easter Sunday 2009, U.S. Army infantryman Brendan Marrocco doesn’t even come close to showing the kind of emotional cracks to his confidence many others would surely face, including me.

To look at photos of Marrocco, 23 during his year-long rehabilitation at Walter Reed Army Medical Center is to witness a strength of character and a tenacity for life that is both indomitable and inspiring. Since the first of both wars began in 2001, 988 service members have lost limbs in combat-related injuries. Marrocco is only the second quadruple amputee.

Looking at his website and reading about the intense level of rehab Marrocco has devoted himself to over the last year, I kept wondering what he thinks when he turns on the news, watches protestors, or listens to pundits rant, not only about the war, but the multitude of issues that confront the country. I’m hoping he doesn’t watch any of it.

I wonder what Marrocco’s reaction would be to self-proclaimed “America’s Truth Detector” Rush Limbaugh’s statement (June 23, 2010) that Obama is “the first president in history – to my knowledge – who actually wants his nation to fail.”

Or when Glenn Beck warned on Fox News (June 10, 2010) that “the summer of rage is about to begin.”

“In most communities,” President Dwight Eisenhower said, “it is illegal to cry ‘fire’ in a crowded assembly. Should it not be considered serious international misconduct to manufacture a general war scare in an effort to achieve local political aims?”

I’m concerned when I hear a gathering of doomsayers and gun-toting rageaholics loudly proclaim “their rights” while, at the same time, ignore their responsibilities.

The democracy I live in should be about respectful, responsible speech, not arrogant, polarizing demagoguery. Sadly, there will always be those who favor fear over faith, choose unreason over common sense. It is their right to do so. However, it is neither admirable nor ethical to try to influence millions through misinformation, innuendo and lies under the guise of patriotism.

“Outrage is easy, cheap and oversold,” former New York Governor Mario Cuomo wrote in his 1995 book Reason to Believe. “The nation needs less anger and more thoughtful reflection, less shouting and more listening, less dissembling and more honesty.

“In analyzing the issues, we need to remember there is a place for ideology, but it is not first place. First place goes to good sense, no matter what political badge it happens to be wearing at the moment. Sometimes that’s common sense… other times it may mean uncommon sense. We need to get beyond the beguiling simplistics and sound bites, blow away the blue smoke, take down the political mirrors, and be willing to accept the truth when we find it.”

All of us could use a lot less noise, smoke and mirrors, and a lot more thoughtful deliberation – if for no other reason than to honor the sacrifice of people like Brendan Marrocco.

Patriotism doesn’t mean that we blindly support every policy elected officials put forth. It means that we should act in a responsible and respectful manner regardless on which side of the political issue we stand.

Comments

Leave a Comment



Read More Articles
The Latest... And Sometimes Greatest
Two Greeks Walk into an A.I. Bar . . .
…and spot Donald Trump holding court. Curious, they approach and begin a conversation. Socrates: Tell me, sir, what is the nature of leadership? Is it...
February 8, 2025
Dispatches From the Front
Let me get this straight: … the Senate will vote to approve a woman with ties to authoritarian leaders, a man who has pushed vaccine...
February 5, 2025
Godfather, Part Now
“I don’t feel I have to wipe everyone out, Tom, just my enemies.”—Michael Corleone, The Godfather Note: I must pause my earlier commentary suggesting how...
February 3, 2025
The Political System Explained (from the opening of my doctoral thesis)
(Note: this is a rough draft and still undergoing revisions.) Welcome, esteemed colleagues, to a comprehensive exploration of one of the most perplexing and confounding...
January 30, 2025
Something Like a War
I’ve been revisiting Ken Burns’ series on the history of baseball, and it sparked some interesting comparisons to a subject that headlines the news daily....
January 27, 2025
Descaling Our Psyches
I recently descaled my espresso machine—removed the limescale buildup that hinders efficiency. How might we descale the returning president from our psyches? Donald Trump has...
January 23, 2025