When Principle Meets Prejudice

Published: June 25, 2025

By Jim Lichtman
Image
Read More

As President Donald Trump celebrated the 250th anniversary of the U.S. military, one soldier was under attack.

At Fort Drum, New York, Maj. Erica Vandal glanced at her phone. A message from her mother: “Just heard about the Supreme Court ruling. That totally stinks! How are you doing?”

The court had just allowed Trump’s ban on transgender troops to take effect, effectively ending the military career Vandal had built over 14 years.

Recently, in a federal courtroom in Massachusetts, another fight was underway. Judge William Young ruled that the administration’s cuts to NIH grants were “void and illegal,” calling out its discrimination against Black communities, women, and LGBTQ individuals. That’s what this is,” Young said. Racial discrimination and discrimination against America’s LGBTQ community.

Two stories, one theme: a government turning its back on the very people it should protect.

For Major Vandal, the ruling cut deep. Raised in a military family, shaped by values of duty, integrity, and sacrifice, she followed her father—an Army three-star—into West Point, artillery, and combat in Afghanistan. In a culture that demands conformity, she lived quietly with a truth she could no longer ignore: she was transgender.

In 2021, President Biden lifted the ban, allowing her and thousands of others to serve openly. But with Trump’s return, that protection vanished. Vandal now faced an impossible choice: accept a payout and leave the Army, or fight a degrading legal battle to prove her worth to a system rigged against her.

This was more than politics. The Pentagon’s new order questioned her honesty and morality—qualities once praised in her officer evaluations. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s crude rally cry—“No more dudes in dresses”—made clear just how far some of our leaders had fallen.

Meanwhile, in Judge Young’s courtroom, the fight for dignity continued. The administration’s cuts weren’t about saving money. They targeted communities already struggling: Black Americans, women, LGBTQ people. The court named what others would not: this was discrimination, plain and simple.

Both rulings reveal a deeper concern: how prejudice, disguised as policy, can unravel lives. It reduces America’s highest ideals—equal justice, dignity for all—to little more than empty words.

And yet, there is courage. Vandal joined a lawsuit to block the military ban. Young’s ruling forced the government, at least for now, to restore funding for those in need. Neither fight is over. But both show the power of standing up even when standing alone.

In the end, what’s at stake is more than careers or funding. It is the character of the nation: whether we allow fear and bigotry to decide who belongs, who serves, who is worthy of dignity.

As Major Vandal told a young trans Navy recruit unsure about suing the military: “I grew up in a military family. I never thought I’d be involved in a case against the military.”

Few ever think they will have to fight their own government for their place in it. But in moments like these, those fights become acts of principle against prejudice, against exclusion. They remind us that the promise of America belongs to all or it belongs to none.

Comments

Leave a Comment



Read More Articles
The Latest... And Sometimes Greatest
The Man Who Helped America Believe in Itself Again
The Great Depression didn’t begin with the crash of ’29. It started earlier—quietly, steadily—beneath the surface of a country convinced the good times would never...
July 28, 2025
The Conscience of Government
If I had my way, every candidate who wins a primary election for public office—from Congress to the presidency—would be required to pass through a...
July 24, 2025
Are We Asking the Right Questions?
A recent graduation speech by a young philosophy major, Clair Doyle, at Northwestern University in Illinois, began with a deceptively simple question that stopped me...
July 21, 2025
When Power Rewrote the Message
When the pulpit merges with power, does the sword overshadow the Sermon on the Mount? Though I’m no longer practicing, I was raised Catholic. I...
July 17, 2025
It’s Superman, Strange Visitor from Another Planet…
Superman—America’s original superhero—once stood tall as a symbol of everything this country aspired to be. Superman—who embodies courage, decency, and fairness. Superman—who fights for the...
July 14, 2025
What J.D. Vance No Longer Stands For
Once celebrated as the thoughtful author of Hillbilly Elegy, Vance’s rise to the vice presidency is a lesson in political transformation—and not for the better....
July 11, 2025