Credit: .J. Scott Applewhite/Associated Press

In 2012, Justice David Souter—long retired, rarely seen—offered a quiet but powerful warning during a talk in New Hampshire. Reflecting on the erosion of civic understanding, he said:

“What I worry about is that when problems are not addressed, people will not know who is responsible. And when the problems get bad enough—as they might—some one person will come forward and say, ‘Give me total power and I will solve this problem.’ That is how the Roman Republic fell.”

He wasn’t being dramatic. He was being honest.

Today, we are living in the shadow of that warning.

We’ve seen a president lie with impunity, attack democratic institutions, fire or layoff thousands of government employees—most notably inspectors general whose job it is to oversee waste fraud and abuse. He urges followers to believe only him, either in word or by silence. And millions cheer—not because the facts support it, but because the narrative feels better than the truth.

Grievance has replaced civic reasoning. Loyalty has replaced accountability. And facts—once the foundation of public discourse—are now treated as disposable.

Democracy doesn’t survive on autopilot. It depends on citizens who can tell the difference between leadership and manipulation, truth and performance. When we ignore that distinction, we normalize lies, excuse threats, and degrade the very structure we claim to defend.

Some people don’t want to face the truth because it would mean admitting that the person they supported violated not just political norms but ethical ones. So they double down. They attack the messenger. They blame everyone but the man at the center of the storm.

That’s not civic engagement. That’s denial. And denial has a cost.

This isn’t hyperbole. It’s history. Democracies rarely fall all at once. They fade—when people stop asking questions, stop seeking truth, stop holding leaders to account. We don’t need to agree on every issue. But we must agree on the rules of the road: truth matters. Ethics matter. Democracy matters. Because once we stop caring about those things, it’s not just a political party that’s at risk.

It’s the republic itself.

So what now?

Speak up. Don’t let lies go unchallenged. You don’t have to shout. But you do need to show up. Support leaders of character—not just charisma. Elevate truth over volume. And remember: it’s not about being right. It’s about doing right.

Because the real danger isn’t just that facts no longer matter to some—it’s that we let them stop mattering to us.