The Unconventionalist

Published: December 2, 2020

By Jim Lichtman
Image
Read More

In his Peace Studies class at Bethesda-Chevy Chase High School, Colman McCarthy engages students in his chosen religion: nonviolence and peace.

“If peace is what every government says it seeks,” McCarthy writes, “and peace is the yearning of every heart, why aren’t we studying it and teaching it in school?”

In Reverend McCarthy’s weekly sermon, “studying peace through nonviolence is as much about getting the bombs out of our hearts as it is about getting them out of the Pentagon budget.”

And that is precisely the purpose of his high school class. (It’s a shame that Pentagon officials don’t attend his class. They might actually learn how to cut the arms budget.)

Regardless, McCarthy has enlisted guest speakers from Nobel laureates to the school’s cleaning lady who fled El Salvador. All have something to teach the class. All are volunteers, just like McCarthy who doesn’t receive a paycheck for his work.

“Students,” McCarthy writes, “or at least the wary ones, often say they are glad former flower children like me occasionally turn up on college faculties, but in the real world nonviolence won’t work and hasn’t worked. Look what happened, they say, to Jesus, Gandhi, King, and a lot of other pacifists.

“I answer with the only honest reply available. Nonviolence is a risky philosophy to live by. It is no guarantee of safety. All that can be said of it is that it’s less a failure than violence. Those who prefer violent force,” McCarthy stresses, “must justify the deaths of this century’s 78 million war victims. The number is a 500 percent increase over the last century.”

A recent profile on CBS Sunday Morning has moved McCarthy’s religion of peace back onto the front burner of our attention. And considering all the fire and dysfunction that defines our nation’s capital, we need lawmakers who understand that the only way we can even begin to bridge the divide in the country is through peace.

“We can’t become what we need to be by remaining what we are,” Oprah Winfrey says. And Colman McCarthy instructs his students in becoming what we all need to be: peacemakers.

While McCarthy may be facing an uphill battle, he causes his students to think — think about their responsibility, not only to their local community but the the world community.

At the beginning of each semester, McCarthy asks his students if they can identify the following: U.S. Grant, Robert E. Lee, Dwight Eisenhower, George Patton, William Westmoreland, Jane Adams, Jeannette Rankin, A.J. Muste, Adin Ballou and Dorothy Day.

“All can identify the first five,” McCarthy says, “but it’s rare if anyone knows the second five, all believers or practitioners of nonviolence.”

I would add one more name to that list: Colman McCarthy.

Comments

  1. Yes Jim, we could all learn from these peacemakers: Colman McCarthy, Jane Adams, Jeannette Rankin, A.J. Muste, Adin Ballou and Dorothy Day.

Leave a Comment



Read More Articles
The Latest... And Sometimes Greatest
Who We Were. Who We Are…
Today, America is 250 years old. This Fourth of July, amid deep national division, it seems worth asking a simple question: Which of our country’s...
July 4, 2026
Are We Still Worthy of What They Declared?
Conclusion: The Words That Made Us and Still Must.  In December of 1776, the Revolution was not moving toward triumph. It was close to collapse....
July 3, 2026
Are We Still Worthy of What They Declared?
Part 2: Common Sense Are we still capable of that kind of clarity when it matters most? There was a moment in the birth of...
July 1, 2026
Are We Still Worthy of What They Declared?
For the most part, my high school history classes consisted of names, dates, documents, and battles. What I’ve learned since then — through historians like...
June 29, 2026
A Cautionary Tale: France Then, Washington Now
Lately, I’ve been reading more history, mostly to educate myself. But the other night, I opened Lord Acton’s Lectures on the French Revolution and didn’t...
June 25, 2026
Different Issues. Same Fear.
As our nation nears its 250th anniversary, an uneasy emotional connection to the past has returned—one rooted in fear, and the question of who gets...
June 22, 2026