Profiles in Republican Courage

Published: June 27, 2025

By Jim Lichtman
Image
Read More

Three U.S. Senators. Three Republicans. All support the Constitution and their conscience: Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, Susan Collins of Maine, and Rand Paul of Kentucky—have shown that moral conviction and independent judgment can still find a place in public service.

Lisa Murkowski has emerged as one of the Senate’s most principled voices. Following the January 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol, she was one of only seven Republican senators to vote to convict Donald Trump during his second impeachment trial. “The president’s actions that preceded the riot were a betrayal of his oath of office,” she said. That decision brought political backlash, including a formal censure by the Alaska Republican Party. And yet, Murkowski stayed the course. She has continued to work across the aisle on critical issues—supporting bipartisan infrastructure legislation, voting rights protections, and efforts to preserve democratic norms. Her actions reflect a commitment to governance over grievance and to country over party.

Susan Collins has long walked the line between Republican orthodoxy and centrist independence. Like Murkowski, she voted to convict Trump following the Capitol insurrection—an act grounded in her defense of constitutional order. Collins also supported the confirmation of Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson—the only Republican to do so outside of Murkowski and Mitt Romney—placing qualifications above partisan considerations. While often criticized for her cautious tone, Collins has remained a steady advocate for institutional integrity, moderation, and the rule of law—values that once defined a more principled Republican tradition.

Then there is Rand Paul, whose libertarian philosophy frequently puts him at odds with both major parties. Paul’s convictions are rooted in constitutional principle. He has been a consistent defender of civil liberties—challenging warrantless surveillance, opposing unchecked executive authority, and speaking out against a widely supported TikTok ban on First Amendment grounds. While not the architect of any recent tariff rollback, Paul has voiced concern over the use of national emergency declarations to bypass congressional authority—especially in the context of trade policy. He’s also reached across the aisle to support reforms in animal welfare and scientific testing. His work reminds us that not every conviction need be shaped by the culture wars.

Each of these senators acts from a different philosophical base—Murkowski from a devotion to democratic institutions, Collins from a tradition of reasoned governance, and Paul from libertarian principle. What unites them is a willingness to act in accordance with conscience rather than convenience. They are not above criticism, and each has made controversial choices. But in a time when political courage is rare, their examples matter.

At a moment when too many elected officials chase polls or retreat into partisan echo chambers, Murkowski, Collins, and Paul offer something different. They show that character still matters. That standing for principle—even when unpopular—is not only possible, but essential to the health of a functioning democracy.

Comments

Leave a Comment



Read More Articles
The Latest... And Sometimes Greatest
How High Can Leadership Rise?
What is power accountable to when it no longer accepts limits? We have seen what happens when power turns inward—when it begins to believe it...
April 20, 2026
The Burden of Command
What does leadership require when decisions send others into harm’s way, and uncertainty is shared not just by those in command, but by the nation...
April 16, 2026
“If I wasn’t in the White House, Leo wouldn’t be in the Vatican”
Question: How low can Donald Trump go?Answer: Low enough to attack the head of the Catholic Church and, by extension, 1.4 billion Catholics. His latest...
April 13, 2026
We
What will define us at 250 years—not our disagreements, but what we are willing to believe about one another, and about the truth itself? As...
April 9, 2026
An Easter Message That Matters
On Thursday, three days before Easter Sunday, Pope Leo XIV delivered a message that went straight to the point. “Leadership is not measured by authority,...
April 4, 2026
The Man Who Feared What We Might Become
Since my dinner with Jefferson, Hamilton, and Madison, I’ve been reading more about James Madison, who’s often called the father of the Constitution. What struck...
March 30, 2026