The Enemy Within

Published: September 10, 2024

By Jim Lichtman
Image
Read More

In 63 BCE, Rome was facing an internal crisis that threatened to destroy the Republic.

Roman senator Lucius Sergius Catilina, known as Catiline, was conspiring to overthrow the government. With the help of a coalition of the discontented, his plan included violent uprisings and the assassination of several leading senators and political figures, including Cicero, Rome’s famed philosopher and statesman.

However, Cicero learned of Catiline’s plot through a network of spies and allies within the Senate. He also received information from conspirators who turned against Catiline once they realized their involvement could lead to a death sentence. Moreover, Catiline’s behavior and statements helped expose the conspiracy: his inflammatory public speeches, relentless pursuit of the consulship, and open recruitment of criminals and corrupt allies made his intentions unmistakable.

Having pieced together the plan, Cicero, the greatest orator of his time, gave a series of speeches to the Senate that spoke of the clear and present danger Catiline posed to the Republic.

When, O Catiline, do you mean to cease abusing our patience? How long is that madness of yours still to mock us? When is there to be an end of that unbridled audacity of yours, swaggering about as it does now?

“Do you not feel that your plans are detected? Do you not see that your conspiracy is already arrested and rendered powerless by the knowledge which every one here possesses of it?”

With Cicero’s compelling oratory and mounting evidence, the Senate crushed the rebellion leaving Cataline to escape Rome and avoid the consequences of his actions.

The last time a U.S. senator stood up to expose a plot against the principles of honesty and fairness occurred on June 1, 1950. In a moment reflective of Cicero, Republican Senator Margaret Chase Smith delivered her “Declaration of Conscience” speech, condemning the reckless anti-communist tactics of her Senate colleague, Joseph R. McCarthy. With powerful rhetoric, Chase Smith exemplified the moral backbone and political courage in challenging McCarthy’s smear campaign against alleged communists.

I am proud of the fact that the Republican Party has always been a party of sound judgment and of decency. I am proud of the fact that the Republican Party has been a party of integrity and of honor. . .

“I am not proud of the conduct of some of my colleagues who have used the power and the prestige of this Senate to attack and to malign innocent people. . . to spread fear and stifle dissent . . . .

“I am not proud of the fact that some of my colleagues have used the power and the prestige of this Senate to attack and to malign the very spirit of equality and of justice that has made this nation a shining example to the world.”

At the end of her address, the junior Senator from Maine received a standing ovation from Republicans and Democrats. Soon after, Edward R. Murrow, the most influential figure in American media, detailed the dangers of McCarthy’s actions to the public through a series of powerful broadcasts, which quickly led to McCarthy’s downfall.

Are we capable of learning from history’s lessons? Can we rise above our cultural and political biases to foster a culture of reflection, open-mindedness, and humility?

Comments

Leave a Comment



Read More Articles
The Latest... And Sometimes Greatest
A New Pearl of Great Price: Blind Faith in Trump
Legend has it that a man once approached the Jewish sage Hillel the Elder with a challenge: if he could sum up the principles of...
September 6, 2024
Our Better Angels Better Show Up
A good friend and I have what we call our “Best Friends Thursday” lunches, where we catch up on the events of the day, primarily...
September 3, 2024
NY Times: More than 200 Bush, McCain and Romney Staffers Endorse Harris
Bush, McCain, and Romney Alumni for Harris Statement “Four years ago, President George W. Bush, the late Sen. John McCain, and then-Gov. Mitt Romney alumni...
August 27, 2024
What Would Lincoln Say?
In the midst of relentless hyper-partisanship and division, I wondered what Abraham Lincoln’s take would be. Here’s what he might have said. “America can be...
July 23, 2024
When Hate Becomes the Only Answer
Embed from Getty Images Saturday’s attempted assassination of former President Donald Trump is a stark sign that political hate speech has taken on an urgency...
July 15, 2024
The Ethics of AI
Last Tuesday, I informed readers that I used an AI program to create a commentary celebrating the 4th of July. The program is ChatGPT, a...
July 12, 2024