Separating Fact from Rhetoric

Published: March 12, 2026

By Jim Lichtman
Image
Read More

SPECIAL REPORT 

I recently received an email message from a nationwide grassroots political network. The message reads as follows:

“The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is spending millions on warehouses they plan to repurpose as ICE detention ‘mega-centers’ to hold as many as 10,000 human beings per warehouse.

“Draft layouts show ‘pods’ in which individuals are to be held, each pod crammed tightly against the next. The risks and trauma inherent to such crowding almost don’t bear mentioning — because to do so suggests a world in which there is a good way to warehouse human beings. There isn’t.

“Across the country, concerned Americans have already shown they’re unwilling to sit by as these new concentration camps are built and filled. Instead, they’ve been fighting back and winning — even in some deep red districts.

“In Utah, Minnesota, and Oklahoma, from Marshall County, MS to Hanover County, VA, grassroots pressure has swayed politicians and property owners, successfully preventing the sale of commercial spaces to DHS.

“Some progressive politicians have joined the fight, and the growing backlash has scared even a few Republicans into opposing the purchase of these properties by DHS — at least, in their own backyards — while putting everyone else, even the most loyal MAGA elected officials, on the defensive.

“Which makes this the perfect time to go on offense. Email all your Members of Congress now and tell them you expect them to do everything in their power to block the warehousing of humans.”

While I stand four-square against the Trump administration’s immigration policies and actions, they still deserve to be examined against the facts, so I took a closer look. Here’s what I found through an AI program:

“A review of credible reporting tells a more measured story than the one spreading across social media. The Department of Homeland Security has explored ways to expand immigration detention capacity, including the possible use of large commercial buildings or warehouses as detention facilities.

“Several news organizations have reported on proposals to lease or purchase such properties as part of a broader effort to increase the number of available detention beds. In some communities, local officials and residents have objected, and in a few cases, that pressure has slowed or stopped proposed deals.

“But much of the language now circulating online—terms like ‘concentration camps,’ detailed descriptions of packed ‘pods,’ and sweeping claims that communities across the country are successfully blocking these projects—comes largely from advocacy campaigns rather than verified reporting.

“The policy debate itself is real, and it deserves serious scrutiny. Yet the viral narrative often blurs the line between confirmed facts and political messaging.

“The evidence points to a familiar problem in the digital age: a real issue wrapped in rhetoric that runs well ahead of what the facts actually show.”

Final analysis: I’m all for active protest through a variety of methods including letters and emails to all members of Congress. But be careful of the Confirmation Bias trap in rhetoric that’s clearly meant to inflame.

Comments

Leave a Comment



Read More Articles
The Latest... And Sometimes Greatest
“If I wasn’t in the White House, Leo wouldn’t be in the Vatican”
Question: How low can Donald Trump go?Answer: Low enough to attack the head of the Catholic Church and, by extension, 1.4 billion Catholics. His latest...
April 13, 2026
We
What will define us at 250 years—not our disagreements, but what we are willing to believe about one another, and about the truth itself? As...
April 9, 2026
An Easter Message That Matters
On Thursday, three days before Easter Sunday, Pope Leo XIV delivered a message that went straight to the point. “Leadership is not measured by authority,...
April 4, 2026
The Man Who Feared What We Might Become
Since my dinner with Jefferson, Hamilton, and Madison, I’ve been reading more about James Madison, who’s often called the father of the Constitution. What struck...
March 30, 2026
Same Price. Same War. Different Truth
In the winter of 1863, as the Civil War dragged into its third year, prices in the North rose sharply. Coffee, flour, and coal steadily...
March 25, 2026
Who Writes This Stuff: Jim or A.I.?
With the incredible rise of artificial intelligence comes a set of questions, among them: Did the writer write the text, or did A.I.? Or… maybe...
March 23, 2026