Loose Lips…

Published: October 7, 2013

By Jim Lichtman
Image
Read More

Okay, boys and girls, it’s ethical dilemma time!

Last week, two politicians were caught, on an open mic, sharing strategy points.

Moments before Senate Minority Leader McConnell was due to be interviewed on MSNBC, this brief conversation occurred with Senator Paul:

McConnell (as Paul walks up): I’m all wired-up, here.

Paul: I just did CNN, and I just go over and over again, “We’re willing to compromise. Were willing to negotiate”… I don’t think they [the Democrats] poll tested “we won’t negotiate.” I think it’s awful for them to say that over and over again.

McConnell: Yeah, I do too and I just came back from that two hour meeting with them, and that was basically the same view privately as it was publicly.

Paul: I think if we keep saying, “We wanted to defund [Obamacare], we fought for that and now we’re willing to compromise on this,” I think they [the Democrats] can’t, we’re gonna, I think, well I know we don’t want to be here, but we’re gonna win this, I think.

Conclusion: Republicans are caught saying one thing, but privately confirm that they’re unwilling to compromise.

But this commentary is not about that point. Most Americans agree that the government shutdown is about partisan gamesmanship and have a strong distaste for it.

I want readers to respond to this question: From an ethical standpoint, is it fair for the media to air, what intended to be, a private conversation between colleagues, or do they have a duty to report any and all remarks – even those which may have been intended to be private – in order to let the public witness, firsthand, the real motivation of politicians?

Also, based on your opinion, how would you finish the title of this commentary: “Loose Lips…”

Comments

Leave a Comment



Read More Articles
The Latest... And Sometimes Greatest
A New Pearl of Great Price: Blind Faith in Trump
Legend has it that a man once approached the Jewish sage Hillel the Elder with a challenge: if he could sum up the principles of...
September 6, 2024
Our Better Angels Better Show Up
A good friend and I have what we call our “Best Friends Thursday” lunches, where we catch up on the events of the day, primarily...
September 3, 2024
NY Times: More than 200 Bush, McCain and Romney Staffers Endorse Harris
Bush, McCain, and Romney Alumni for Harris Statement “Four years ago, President George W. Bush, the late Sen. John McCain, and then-Gov. Mitt Romney alumni...
August 27, 2024
What Would Lincoln Say?
In the midst of relentless hyper-partisanship and division, I wondered what Abraham Lincoln’s take would be. Here’s what he might have said. “America can be...
July 23, 2024
When Hate Becomes the Only Answer
Embed from Getty Images Saturday’s attempted assassination of former President Donald Trump is a stark sign that political hate speech has taken on an urgency...
July 15, 2024
The Ethics of AI
Last Tuesday, I informed readers that I used an AI program to create a commentary celebrating the 4th of July. The program is ChatGPT, a...
July 12, 2024