Ground Rules

Published: April 27, 2012

By Jim Lichtman
Image
Read More

From January 1 to December 31, 2007 I decided to search, read and clip all the ethics-related stories I could find from The New York Times and Washington Post. The final count totaled 1,657 ethics-related stories. That’s an average of 4.5 stories per day.

Looking at today’s (Apr. 26) Times and Post, here’s what I found:

The Times –

Fall of Chinese Official is tied to Wiretapping

Murdoch, Center Stage, Plays Powerless Broker (re: phone-hacking scandal)

British Government’s Ties to Murdochs Scrutinized (side-bar)

Disgraced Chinese Official’s Son Tries to Defuse Sports Car Scandal

Two Abuse Victims Testify at Church Official’s Trial

After Recalls and Missteps, J&J’s New Chief Confronts Critical Challenges

Ex-Morgan Stanley Official Pleads Guilty to Violating Anticorruption Laws

After Man’s Death, Scrutiny for a Police Chase (re: a police chase where a 27-year-old man was caught by police removing material from a housing project. While being chased, the police car swerved to block his escape and the man was struck and killed.)

Marine to be discharged for Anti-Obama Posts on Facebook(among the soldier’s statements: “Screw Obama and I will not follow all orders from him.”

Laker [basketball player Metta World Peace] cites ‘Passion,’ Not Anger, in Elbowing. If you haven’t seen the video on this, the opposing team member was violently knocked to the floor by an un-peaceful Laker player.

The Post –

John Edwards’s Defense Challenges Ex-aide’s Credibility at Corruption Trial

New Secret Service Allegations Surface

2 Witnesses in 1985 D.C. Murder Trial Claim Coercion by Police, Prosecutors

Racist Tweet Storm about Joel Ward… Another Ugly Mark for NHL

We Need More Accountability in Afghanistan (op-ed: misconduct by U.S. soldiers)

That’s 15 ethics-related scandals from two papers in a singleday!

Each time I read one of these stories the same issues surface: accountability, respect, responsibility, self-restraint, honesty, civility, fairness, integrity.

The usual follow-up after an incident is the acknowledgment that an investigation has begun with appropriate measures to follow for the wrong-doers.

But what happens after that? What considerations are made for changing or correcting the ethical culture? What can an organization due to promote good behavior?

Here are a few steps to consider –

First, review with participants the purpose of an ethics program:

1) Provide a framework for seeing and dealing with tough, gray-area problems.

2) Clarify and emphasize personal ethical values.

3) Identify and discuss organizational and systemic factors that make it difficult consistently to live up to the highest ethical aspirations.

4) Develop practical strategies to improve institutional and personal decision making.

Second, go through the process of ethical decision making:

1) Who are the stakeholders; which have special claims?: a/ Professional obligations; b/ Personal relationships of trust; c/ Examine the gravity of the “stake.”

2) What ethical principles are involved?

3) What can be done to avoid an ethical violation without undermining the goal?

4) What are the major options?

Third, strengthen problem-solving ability:

1) Push participants to decide; to draw some line by identifying which options are ethically unacceptable.

2) Point out how participants deal with ambiguous facts, reveals their value priorities.

3) Probe: Who should be involved in the decision; who should be consulted first; who should be informed and in what sequence?

4) Anticipate problems of implementation.

5) What mechanisms for monitoring decisions are available?

6) How could the problem have been avoided? Is there anything that can or should be done now to avoid similar situations?

Remember, ethics is not just another set of criteria to consider in decision making. Ethics should always be treated as groundrules of behavior.

Comments

Leave a Comment



Read More Articles
The Latest... And Sometimes Greatest
Two Greeks Walk into an A.I. Bar . . .
…and spot Donald Trump holding court. Curious, they approach and begin a conversation. Socrates: Tell me, sir, what is the nature of leadership? Is it...
February 8, 2025
Dispatches From the Front
Let me get this straight: … the Senate will vote to approve a woman with ties to authoritarian leaders, a man who has pushed vaccine...
February 5, 2025
Godfather, Part Now
“I don’t feel I have to wipe everyone out, Tom, just my enemies.”—Michael Corleone, The Godfather Note: I must pause my earlier commentary suggesting how...
February 3, 2025
The Political System Explained (from the opening of my doctoral thesis)
(Note: this is a rough draft and still undergoing revisions.) Welcome, esteemed colleagues, to a comprehensive exploration of one of the most perplexing and confounding...
January 30, 2025
Something Like a War
I’ve been revisiting Ken Burns’ series on the history of baseball, and it sparked some interesting comparisons to a subject that headlines the news daily....
January 27, 2025
Descaling Our Psyches
I recently descaled my espresso machine—removed the limescale buildup that hinders efficiency. How might we descale the returning president from our psyches? Donald Trump has...
January 23, 2025