“Guilty, Your Honor”

Published: December 2, 2011

By Jim Lichtman
Image
Read More

I’ve written about Major John Baldwin, (Ret.) before. A vascular surgeon who served with distinction in Viet Nam and several hospitals after the war, John’s ‘moment of principle’ was featured in my book, “What Do You Stand For?” John has since become a valued friend and supporter of this writer.

Commenting on ethics in general and Joe Paterno in particular, John included a personal story of honesty and accountability.


“How many times do we have to be shown that the cover-up is FAR WORSE than the crime?  The longer it goes, the greater the ultimate damage.

“Forty years ago I was stopped for ‘weaving’ in my car and was given a DUI for 0.08. In court, six weeks later, the judge, standing before me and about 12 others I recognized from my night in jail, said, ‘How do you plead?’

“ ‘Guilty, your honor,’ I replied.

“He was shocked, turned to the court clerk and asked, ‘Has this man ever been arrested before?’  ‘NO’ was the reply.  Turning to the full courtroom with the other 12 and their parents and lawyers, he said, ‘Let this be a lesson. This man has told the truth. His sentence will be two days of community service, no fine and nothing will be on his record. Let the rest of you take note.’

“I enjoyed emptying desk-side paper trash at the welfare building and on my second day, one lady asked my supervisor, ‘Will John be here permanently?  He is a wonderful person.’

“I learned a lot from that episode, and son William used it quite well when he had taken things from a parked car at age 16 three years ago. Of the four boys, he was the only one who admitted guilt, and as a consequence he went on to get his high school diploma, whereas the others went to juvenile jail.

“Me, I never drove after drinking after that, and realized that cover-ups and lying only get you deeper into the hole.”

John’s actions regarding his DUI may not rise to the level of reporting child-abuse, but the principle remains the same, Be Responsible: think before you act, consider the possible consequences on all people affected by your actions; be accountable, “take your medicine”; accept responsibility for the consequences of your choices; be reliable; set a good example; don’t blame others for your mistakes or take credit for other’s achievements; exercise self-control; be disciplined.

Thanks, John.

 

Comments

Leave a Comment



Read More Articles
The Latest... And Sometimes Greatest
The Quiet Strength of Pope Francis
I liked Francis—a lot. How could you not? He spoke plainly, with sincerity and purpose—and people listened. His words weren’t wrapped in rhetoric; they were...
April 23, 2025
We Need to Believe in Ourselves Again
A forward to today’s commentary– The death of Pope Francis is a reminder of the kind of ethical leadership the world too often lacks and...
April 21, 2025
The Courage To Act
Embed from Getty Images Ethics begins where self-interest ends. We’re facing a moment that goes far beyond politics. This is not about party affiliation or...
April 18, 2025
The Quiet Conscience of Justice Potter Stewart
Today’s Supreme Court is mired in partisanship and shadow rulings, where politics too often outweigh principle. Public trust continues to deteriorate for an institution meant...
April 16, 2025
Good Night, and Good Luck… to Us All
Good Night, and Good Luck, starring George Clooney on Broadway is a wake-up call about the ethical courage we desperately need today—a timely parable based...
April 14, 2025
The Immaculate Contradiction
A timely Opinion piece in The New York Times by David French sheds greater light on why so many Evangelical Christians fervently believe in Donald...
April 11, 2025