Mr. Specter’s Choice

Published: April 29, 2009

By Jim Lichtman
Image
Read More

The big political news on both the Internet and cable channels was not President Obama’s “First 100 Days.”  It was the announcement from the five-term former Republican Senator from Pennsylvania.

“In a stunning turnabout in political loyalties,” the New York Times reported, “Senator Arlen Specter of Pennsylvania… announced he was leaving the Republican Party to become a Democrat.”

Was it due to a change in principle?

“Mr. Specter,” the Times said, “had concluded from his own polling and travels through his state that he could not survive a Republican primary against a conservative candidate and would instead align with a Democratic Party he said was more compatible to his political views.”

Now, while I’d like to believe the later, the former seems to be the real truth.

“Mr. Specter, who spoke with Mr. Obama before making his decision public, said he had commitments from the president and Senate Democratic leaders to support him in any primary challenge next year, pledges that should give him a strong chance to prevail despite his decades as a Republican,” the Times wrote.

And that’s disappointing.  I like Arlen Specter, and have respected his decision-making for years primarily because he does not always vote the party line.

Philadelphia resident Jamie O’Boyle said of the move, “The one thing [Specter] really knows how to do is win elections. The son of Russian Jewish Immigrants, he was a natural-born Democrat, serving as Philadelphia District Attorney in a Democratic administration.  He switched to the Republican Party in 1966, saying something to the effect that ‘I didn’t leave the Democratic Party, they left me.’ Now he can say the same thing about the Republican Party.

“Since the election, the Republican Party in [Pennsylvania] has been purging their ranks of anyone even remotely moderate in a suicidal drive for purity, and that includes Specter. They’re running a hard-liner against him in the Republican primary. In PA only registered members of the party can vote in primaries. Since at least 200,000 Republicans in this state have changed their registration to Democrat in the last few years – and they are likely to be Specter supporters, changing parties guarantees that he’ll be re-elected unless the Democrats do something incredibly stupid.”

However, there’s another issue that concerns me.

I went to Arlen Specter’s own web site.  If you scroll down, you will see a tag that reads, “What’s New.”  Under yesterday’s date, April 28, I could not find a single mention of the switch.  There’s no statement to his constituents about his plans or his reasons why.  There isn’t even a transcript of the public statement he made in Washington.  There is a statement that reads, “Specter Proposes Innovative Agency to Accelerate Cures for Diseases.”  While I have no doubt this is important, frankly it pales in comparison to the news of Specter’s change in political parties.

My question to Senator Specter:  Don’t the people who elected you to office deserve to know your plans and reasons why you’re making such a critical shift before you announce it to the country?

A larger question: Is it fair for any elected official to change political parties after they were elected to office, in large part, by party supporters?

It seems that without as much as a mention to his supporters, Senator Specter has put the business of politics above the business of the people, and that is not fair.

Comments

Leave a Comment



Read More Articles
The Latest... And Sometimes Greatest
Under the Wild Sky, We Gather
Wisconsin’s night sky opened to a rare sight, one usually reserved for places far colder and farther north—the Northern Lights. The colors pulled against each...
November 27, 2025
London, 1943.
In a war that hammered away and left families lying awake at night counting the seconds between sirens, John Gilbert Winant, America’s ambassador to Britain,...
November 25, 2025
Faith in The Goodness of Ordinary People, Even in The Darkest Hours
During his years in wartime London, U.S. Ambassador John Gilbert Winant absorbed the suffering around him. He was known for walking the streets during the...
November 24, 2025
The Forgotten Statesman and the Freedom He Helped Preserve
John Gilbert Winant was one of the rarest of figures in public life: a three-term Republican governor from New Hampshire whose leadership wasn’t calculated but...
November 20, 2025
“What Is Essential Is Invisible to The Eye.”
That line from The Little Prince by French aviator and author, Antoine de Saint-Exupéry is the essence of the story and the essence of what...
November 17, 2025
The Move That Mattered Most
I’ve played chess about two dozen times, and every match feels less like a game and more like mental boot camp. It’s not difficult; it’s...
November 13, 2025